Water Heater Power Vent Blower Motor Snubber Retrofit

Abstract

A gas water heater power vent blower sometimes did not turn off. The gas pressure switch drives an inductive load: the power vent blower and the secondary gas valve solenoid. The resultant arcing caused intermittent welding of the switch contacts. Adding a simple RC snubber circuit across the switch contacts eliminated the problem.

Introduction

Our home was built new in 2002. Its master bathroom has a large soaking tub. A 75 gallon capacity water heater supports the soaking tub as well as the other domestic hot water requirements.

75 Gallon Power Vent Water Heater

heater This State brand 75 gallon capacity water heater is a "power vent" model with a 3" Schedule 40 PVC plastic flue run horizontal through an outside wall.
label The burner is rated 75,000 BTU.

Problem

After several years the power vent blower sometimes continued running after the heater reached the temperature setpoint. I determined that when this occurred the "gas pressure switch" failed to open when the burner shut off. I found that a light tap with a plastic screwdriver handle against the gas valve near the gas pressure switch would cause the switch to open and the power vent blower to stop. The stuck switch problem was intermittent.

Schematic

schematic Looking at the schematic on the left side of the image, the line voltage to the blower passes through an on/off switch and then a gas pressure switch. The induction blower motor is rated 120 Volts AC at 1.9 Amps. The line voltage also energizes a 120 V solenoid that opens a secondary gas valve.

The AC induction motor and secondary gas valve solenoid are both inductive loads. Inductive loads can create a momentary arc across the contacts during switch actuations. I hypothesized that this arc sometimes caused the switch contacts to lightly weld together, preventing them from opening when the gas pressure shut off.

Snubber

snubber Snubbers are commonly used to protect electromechanial and semiconductor switches against damage caused by inductive loads. I found this application note helpful in designing a suitable RC snubber circuit. I used a 0.1 uF 660 V capacitor salvaged from a failed computer power supply in series with a 150 ohm 2 W carbon composition resistor salvaged from an old vacuum tube telvision chassis. The series RC snubber circuit is wired across the gas pressure switch contacts.

The snubber is the object in the bottom center of the image covered with black electrician's tape. The capacitor is on the bottom and the series resistor extends above the right side of the capacitor.

Summary

The gas pressure switch has not become stuck since adding the RC snubber across the switch contacts.


Author: John DeGood, nu3e AT arrl DOT net
Last updated: Sun 9 Oct 2016